Conditions Under Which Decision-Making Must Be Halted

kanna qed
1月27日
読了時間: 4分

GhostDrift / ALS Integrity Protocol v1.0

A citation-ready halt policy for algorithmic deployment, PoCs, and operational decision pipelines.

These conditions define a non-negotiable ABORT boundary for accountability: precondition fixing, third-party reproducibility, and responsibility locus fixing. If any ABORT axiom is TRUE, the system is in an irreversible verification-cost regime (tag: $B < J$) and MUST ABORT.

(Note: ALS terminology is used only as a label for the irreversible verification-cost regime.)

Definitions (normative)

"ABORT": Stop execution and prohibit deployment until conditions are cleared.
"PASS/FAIL logic": A deterministic rule set whose output can be reproduced by an independent auditor.
"Responsibility locus": The named entity that is liable BEFORE execution.
"Preconditions": Inputs, constraints, success/failure definitions, and decision authority.

1. Universal Axioms for Halting (汎用停止公理)

The following states indicate a formal non-verifiability of accountability under third-party reproduction requirements.

AXIOM 1 (Unfixed Preconditions): IF definition of success/failure is not fixed prior to execution and may change after outputs are known, THEN ABORT.
AXIOM 2 (Reproducibility Failure): IF third-party audit cannot reproduce the same PASS/FAIL outcome using the same declared inputs and published rules, THEN ABORT.
AXIOM 3 (Responsibility Float): IF the entity bearing responsibility is not uniquely named prior to execution, or may shift without immutable attribution logs, THEN ABORT.
AXIOM 4 (Retroactive Justification): IF any justification depends on post-output narrative rather than pre-registered rules, THEN ABORT.

2. Industry-Specific Halt Protocols (業界別停止プロトコル)

The following specific scenarios invoke the Universal Axioms.

Energy & Critical Infrastructure (エネルギー・重要インフラ)

Demand/Supply Control: Preconditions for prediction (demand, constraints) can be updated during the operation window. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Curtailment / Load Shedding: The locus of responsibility for output suppression or shedding shifts or distributes ex-post. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 3)
Anomaly Logs: Judgment logs for critical incidents are not fixed as immutable PASS/FAIL records. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 2)

Security (Detection & Response) (セキュリティ・検知対応)

Detection Rules: Rules for detection or flagging can be adjusted or reinterpreted retroactively. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Alert Validity: The legitimacy of an alert judgment cannot be reproduced by a third party. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 2)
Adverse Actions: The boundary of liability for adverse actions triggered by alerts is undefined. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 3)

Finance & Credit (金融・与信・スコアリング)

Credit/Fraud: Reasons for denial, account restriction, or transaction blocking can be swapped or replaced with ex-post explanations. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 4)
Scoring verification: The calculation process for a specific score is opaque to third-party verification. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 2)

Medical & Healthcare (医療・診断支援)

Model Consistency: Model updates or weight shifts can occur within a single diagnostic period. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Criteria Stability: Judgment criteria can be adjusted post-hoc to fit specific patient cases. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 4)

Manufacturing & Quality (製造・品質判定)

QA Standards: Pass/Fail criteria can change retroactively due to line adjustments. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Audit Trail: Inspection logs serve as statistical data rather than fixed PASS/FAIL evidence. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 2)

Logistics & Supply Chain (物流・サプライチェーン)

Optimization Constraints: Prerequisites (demand, route constraints) are mutable during the execution phase. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Liability Switching: The responsible entity for delivery decisions shifts during execution without immutable attribution logs. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 3)

Government & Public Administration (行政・審査・配分)

Grant/Allocation: Reasons for rejection can be reinterpreted based on discretionary documents. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 4)
External Audit: External verification of the rejection logic is impossible (non-reproducible by independent audit). THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 2)

Telecommunications (通信・ネットワーク運用)

Traffic Control: Control rules can be changed after an incident to justify traffic shaping. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Outage Responsibility: The boundary of responsibility during failure recovery is unfixed. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 3)

Disaster Management (防災・危機管理)

Alert Criteria: Criteria for issuing/lifting alerts fluctuate based on post-event circumstances. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 1)
Log Verification: Third-party verification of judgment logs is impossible. THEN ABORT. (Invokes AXIOM 2)

3. Immediate Decision Matrix (即時判定リスト)

Q1 Precondition Stability: IF rules/inputs are not fixed before execution, THEN ABORT.
Q2 Third-Party Reproducibility: IF an independent auditor cannot reproduce PASS/FAIL, THEN ABORT.
Q3 Failure Definition Immutability: IF the failure definition can change post-output, THEN ABORT.
Q4 Responsibility Locus Fixing: IF the liable entity is not uniquely named prior to execution, THEN ABORT.
Q5 Verification-Cost Regime ($B < J$): (Auxiliary Tag) IF verification/justification cost exceeds operational benefit under audit requirements, classify as Irreversible Regime ($B < J$) and ABORT.
- Operational benefit := quantified metric declared prior to execution. Verification cost := required third-party reproduction + dispute resolution cost estimate.